Honestly, I use a wide variety of makeup from high end to drugstore. Really for me it is about the product. I don't believe that all of the high end products are worth it and some of the drugstore makeup just does not cut it.
So when I came across this quad, I thought "Well, why not." The colors seemed right up my alley. I love neutral browns, bronzes, and coppery colors, so this quad seemed to hit it.
Maybelline Stylish Smokes in 02 Natural Smokes
$: $4.88 at Target ($1.22 per shadow!)
The bottom left is a milky white highlight.
The upper left is a taupe color meant for all over the lid.
The upper right is a true brown with gold flecks for the crease.
The bottom right is a dark, matte brown for the outer corner.
I am not in love with the highlight. I find it too chalky and hard to work with. I much more prefer MAC's Blanc Type for better color pay off.
The taupe all-over-lid color is pretty good. A bit sheer but it can be built up to a good amount of opacity. However, I don't particularly like the sheen that it has. Almost like a metallic finish. It was a little bit over the top.
The crease color. Oh, oh boy. This is SUCH a good color! It makes the quad well worth it! The gold flecks in the brown make it such a lovely finish. It isn't too much of a metallic finish like the all over lid shadow, but it isn't flat either. I think this is the best one out of the quad. For me, this is perfect for the outer corner.
The matte brown meant for the outer corner is a tad too dark for my taste, especially for the daytime look. However, it would be great for a nighttime smoky eye.
Swatches:
From L to R: highlight, all over lid color, crease, outer corner
The picture accurately shows the 1st, 2nd and 4th colors. But the 3rd is a little bit more different in real life.
This would be best for travelling. I could probably use this every day, but I would opt for different colors.
Overall, I think that this is a good, inexpensive quad to have. A must have? Ehhh. If you are looking for a drugstore 4-in-1 eyeshadow for, say travelling, you should check this out.